🔗 Share this article

The creamy and indulgent vegetarian curry, referred to as a counterpart of butter chicken, is considered one of the most beloved creations in India's culinary tradition. Culinary expert Vivek Singh has called it “the best-known and frequently reimagined dish in India,” while fellow chefs note its enduring popularity in restaurants throughout the nation.

For those who haven't yet tried the crowd-pleasing charms of soft paneer in a smooth tomato base, this recipe provides a great opportunity to explore it. Paneer makhni (makhni being the Hindi word for butter) feels remarkably elegant, but it’s quite straightforward and fast to prepare. Serve with flatbread and a green dish to turn it into a satisfying dinner.

The Paneer

For many cooking enthusiasts, this unsalted, soft cheese occupies a similar culinary niche as soy cheese, functioning as a pleasingly firm protein-rich ingredient with a blandly creamy taste that flatters, rather than overpowers, whatever sauce it’s paired with. You can make your own fresh cheese using full-fat milk and citric acid, or find it readily available at international markets and larger supermarkets.

Some recipes recommend flavoring the cheese before cooking, typically with a herb mix that provides an vibrant hue. Yet, store-bought cheese can be too dense to absorb much flavour, so marinating may work better with a freshly made cheese.

Other techniques involve preparing the cubes before mixing with the sauce. One popular version mixes the pieces in a combination of garlic, fresh ginger, red pepper, lemon juice, salt, yellow spice, and curd, reminiscent of the technique used for creamy poultry dishes. The cheese is then roasted or crisped to develop a golden crust.

On the other hand, many chefs prefer to fold in the cubes at the last moment of preparation. This method maintains the difference between the squidgy, mild quality of the paneer and the decadent, aromatic base. When cooking for enjoying a stronger taste in the cheese, marinating is highly recommended.

Making the Base

The base of this creamy curry usually starts with sliced onion, grated ginger, and crushed garlic. A few versions use deeply browned onion to deepen the mild flavor, while alternatives rely on aromatic pastes alone. The dairy in this dish give a noticeable sugar that complements with sweet base and root ginger.

In terms of flavorings, this curry generally includes a simple selection of common Indian spices: turmeric, chilli powder, cardamom, and garam masala are standard additions. A few recipes also add jeera, dhania, aromatic mace, or a tej patta. The bright flavor of fresh elaichi works wonderfully with the richness of cream, while the aromatic elements in the spice blend lift the dish’s taste.

Methi leaves, often stirred in at the last stage, are viewed as crucial for their special bitter, slightly woody flavour that provides character to the curry. This addition frequently delivers a clear impact in the completed curry, much like its use in other classic dishes.

For the tomatoes, a silky, creamy feel is highly desirable. If using diced tomatoes, one might want to blend them with a hand blender or push them through a sieve to create a smooth sauce. Or, using finely chopped tomatoes can avoid extra steps.

Without access to ripe, tasty garden tomatoes, it’s not recommended to use them, as poor-quality produce can result in a watery, tart gravy. Several methods additionally use a spoonful of tomato puree to boost the richness. A touch of honey may be added to counter the tomato’s acidity, with choices like white sugar or natural sweetener depending on preference.

Rich Ingredients

As the name implies, butter is a key component in butter paneer, but a range of methods also incorporate other creamy ingredients to boost the decadent feel. Certain cooks use Greek yoghurt, double cream, {single cream|light cream|pour